“The savage in man is never quite eradicated.”
"Confined to a squalid room for months, the emaciated girl was deprived of food and regularly beaten, before she died in excruciating pain in May 2008, weighing just 2st 9lbs. On her death, she was found to have suffered more than two dozen injuries.
Khyra and five other children in the family home in Birmingham were forced to share a single mattress and survive on just a small bowl of food a day, in conditions compared to a "Victorian workhouse" ... Mrs Justice King said: "It is beyond belief that in 2008 in a bustling, energetic and modern city like Birmingham, a child of seven was withdrawn from school and thereafter kept in squalid conditions for a period of five months before finally dying of starvation,” she said.
"This was sustained and punitive brutality to very young children over many months of a type which thankfully is virtually unheard of in this country ... Details of Khyra's suffering emerged at the end of a criminal trial at Birmingham Crown Court into Gordon and Abuhamza, who saw murder charges dropped after both claimed diminished responsibility.
Psychiatrists claimed that Gordon, 35, had suffered major depression at the time of Khyra’s death, while Abuhamza, 30, was a schizophrenic."
Diminished responsibility?!!! A mother who systematically starved one child to death and two out of five other children are nearing death too .. a normal mother would starve herself to death to give her children when needed! That's instinct! But this woman also put all five of them in squalid conditions for months and month on end, has beaten them repeatedly and systematically starved them, while the house was full of food. - only she locked the kitchen door so they can't gain access to this food, which can then be the reserve of herself and her boyfriend! How can that become 'diminished responsibility'??!!! A woman who bought all the food she could get selflessly for her self and her pleasure alone, but at the same time she deprived her own off spring who were treated much below animals, while, at the same time feeding a boyfriend! ... is depressed beyond noticing that her children were dying?! Of hunger?!
schizophrenic or not, that boyfriend looked well fed! And so does this 'monster' of a mother! They were both allowed into the kitchen but not the kids! I wonder, did she cook and feed herself and that man in front of them as well, while those kids were being denied the food? And it wasn't that they were short of money! There was even a tub of ice cream in that crammed with food freezer! But 'majorly depressed' mother here kept that for herself .. and her 'man'! Fancy that! We have ice-cream in the house but it's not for the children, six of them, no less! It's for me, Mum, because I am depressed! Well, if that monster of a woman is so majorly depressed as she claimed - and got away with the murder, why is she after the ice-cream in the first place?! I thought major depression suppresses the appetite, does it?! I have no idea but I imagine it must do if you do lose interest in life, then that may mean losing interest in food too? - I don't know why but I just can't link ice-cream to depression! Maybe because it is a 'happy' food ... :-(
Then again, There was a video on the news where she was giving the children some food because of a party of some sort, so people she didn't want them noticing how cruel she was to her children did not notice, she gave the children some food - but the portion, I do give my cats much more! .. and the excitement on that little girl's face, she was getting any food at all was saddening! Then, another incident when this woman sent the school a letter accusing them of incompetence?! then pulling the children out to educate them at home! .. Then two educational inspectors visit and she has set the scene for them - a make shift classroom, only no children were present! That's premeditation to hide reality, isn't it? Same when teachers visited but she won't open!
.. and the little Khyra used to scavenge for food or steal from other kids at school! Only MUM stopped her even the luxury of doing that! ... and the little girl died slow and she died in agony, beaten, tortured, starved and aged 7! ... and weighing less than 3 stones! This is no depressed woman .. this is a hardened monster .. and this was premeditated murder of the most vicious type! This monster knew, deprivation of food leads to death - that's why she ate despite her presumed depression! Depriving the kids then only means she also knew that something drastic would eventually happen to them one day! Yet she continued with the deprivation, the beatings and the starvation .. and how cold was she when she called the police to inform that her daughter died in her sleep! And that boyfriend, why didn't he call the police - even the natural father too, why didn't he call the police? .. would the police have done anything?
And mum claimed 'diminished responsibility'! What's a murder most savage, most horrid and most barbaric then?!
I mean, if she had shot this child in the head, I would have thought that was the result of temporary insanity - but she didn't, she starved this child to death .. slowly and for months and months!! .. and the other five are in terrible condition too! Because of this woman's cruelty!
This woman is a murderer, she should have got life! and have that served for the full duration too! Minimum! But, she got away on the smaller charge of manslaughter .. and will probably be jailed for just a few years .. then out again to enjoy her 'majorly depressed' life .. with ice-cream!
You know, so long as miscarriages of justice keep on happening like that, there will always be such heart wrenching stories of children being neglected, abused and tortured to death by the vultures they call their parents and, sometimes, carers or other family members! So long as justice is not properly done, why should social services, who did nothing in this case despite many attempts by teachers at that little girl's school, take those children's cases seriously!
The reality is .. nobody cares!
Every now and then we will hear of a similar story like this and we will all rise up weeping for them .. for a while, then things die down until we hear of the following one -- to rise again weeping for the unbearable suffering of those innocent and can't fend for themselves children .. then it's old news again .. and so on ... and given the current status quo, it will continue to be so! and it will keep on happening, again .. and again .. and again ...
You see! Unless you ditch this bureaucracy that leads only to no man's land and therefore stifles efficiency and leads to neglegence in all of the public sector, nothing will change! It is either a 'fully' integrated system that will really be accountable for it's failures, a system that will cooperate to report, to protect and to investigate the dire happenings, in this case, to such vulnerable children - and punish properly when punishment is due. A transparent system and hence, an effecient service that properly connects the police, the educational system to the social system and health system and the legal system .. Together .. or .. nothing at all! ..
And vulnerable kids like Khyra, baby Peter and Victoria .. and many, many others will continue be let down, while those responsible, either the individuals causing the harm or those working for the authorities, escape scot free! Even get rewarded for their incompetence .. or promoted .. or get away with minimal punishment, if at all! And since there is nothing solid in place to stop this waste of people as well as resources, such vulnerable children will keep on dying while not succeeding to survive because of this barbaric failings in our civilised jungle! ... left as it is, people, young and old will die!
.. And Khyra means 'one who hands out goodness'! Only no one handed the poor little girl any! Even her own mother! ...
.. and Justice was not done here judge! :-(
And if this judge could do nothing but to accept the plea of 'diminished responsibility' because of a technicality, then the law is faulty here too!
'Link to Dr Crippen's post on that same subject'
“We weep over the graves of infants and the little ones taken from us by death; but an early grave may be the shortest way to heaven.”